Post Haste: If you want to tax banks, don’t go after reserves
By Michael Hill and Pedro Serôdio
Taxing interest on bank reserves would weaken the Bank of England's control over market interest rates. Raising the bank surcharge offers a more transparent way to tax profits while preserving monetary policy.
Quantitative easing left banks collectively holding reserves they cannot eliminate. Paying interest on those reserves helps the Bank of England transmit its policy rate to the wider economy. Taxing that interest would encourage banks to seek other assets, pushing market rates away from Bank Rate; compelling banks to hold poorly remunerated reserves would instead raise costs that could reach borrowers and savers.
Written with Michael Hill, this piece explains why reserve taxation risks weakening monetary policy and confidence in the terms of future crisis interventions. If the Government wants banks to pay more tax, increasing the bank surcharge is a more transparent route that preserves the machinery used to control inflation.